Bottom line up front: Kegel exercises have a 40-50% success rate when done correctly.[2] Emsella has a 95% success rate.[3] But the differences go much deeper than that. Let's break down exactly why.
The Quick Comparison
| Factor | Kegel Exercises | Emsella Therapy |
|---|---|---|
| Success Rate | 40-50% | 95% |
| Time to Results | 3-6 months | 2-3 weeks |
| Daily Commitment | 100-200 contractions/day | None between sessions |
| Can You Do It Wrong? | Yes (70% do) | No (technology ensures correct form) |
| Cost | Free | $1,800 |
| Contractions Per Session | 100-200 | 11,000 |
How Kegel Exercises Work (And Why They Fail)
What Kegels Are Supposed to Do
Kegel exercises involve voluntarily contracting your pelvic floor muscles — the same muscles you use to stop peeing mid-stream. The theory is simple: strengthen these muscles, improve bladder control.
When done correctly and consistently, they can work. But here's the problem...
Why Most Women Fail at Kegels
Reason 1: You're probably doing them wrong (70% of women are)
Most women squeeze the wrong muscles. They're engaging their:
- Abdominal muscles (bearing down instead of lifting up)
- Glutes (squeezing buttocks)
- Thigh muscles (squeezing legs together)
The pelvic floor is deep inside your pelvis. You can't see it, you can't touch it (externally), and without biofeedback, it's nearly impossible to know if you're engaging the right muscles.
Reason 2: Even if you're doing them correctly, the intensity isn't enough
A voluntary Kegel contraction typically reaches 40-60% of maximum muscle capacity. You're not getting strong enough contractions to rebuild significantly weakened muscles.
Reason 3: The time commitment is unrealistic
You need 100-200 contractions per day, every day, for 3-6 months. That's 15-30 minutes of focused exercises daily. Most people give up after a few weeks.
Reason 4: You can't isolate different parts of the pelvic floor
The pelvic floor isn't one muscle — it's multiple layers working together. Voluntary contractions can't target specific areas that need strengthening.
When Kegels DO Work
Kegels are most effective for:
- Mild incontinence (occasional small leaks)
- Prevention (before you have a problem)
- Young women (better muscle responsiveness)
- Recent onset (within 3-6 months)
If you have moderate to severe incontinence, or you've been doing Kegels for 2-3 months with no improvement, they're probably not going to work.
How Emsella Works (And Why It Succeeds)
The Technology
Emsella uses High-Intensity Focused Electromagnetic (HIFEM) technology to induce supramaximal contractions of the pelvic floor muscles. In simple terms: it forces your muscles to contract with an intensity you could never achieve voluntarily.
What happens during a session:
- You sit fully clothed on the Emsella chair
- Electromagnetic energy penetrates through clothing and tissue
- Directly stimulates pelvic floor motor neurons
- Causes 11,000 contractions in 28 minutes
- Each contraction reaches 100% muscle capacity
Why This Works When Kegels Don't
Advantage 1: Impossible to do wrong
The technology targets the correct muscles automatically. You literally cannot engage the wrong muscles or use improper form.
Advantage 2: Maximum intensity contractions
Each contraction reaches 100% muscle capacity (supramaximal). This is impossible to achieve voluntarily. You're getting 11,000 perfect, maximum-intensity contractions in one session.
Advantage 3: Targets all pelvic floor layers
The electromagnetic field penetrates deep tissue and activates all layers of the pelvic floor simultaneously, including muscles you can't voluntarily control.
Advantage 4: Fast muscle adaptation
The intensity and volume of contractions trigger rapid muscle strengthening and rebuilding. Your body has no choice but to adapt.
Advantage 5: No daily commitment
6 sessions over 3 weeks. No exercises between sessions. Your muscles rest and rebuild while you go about your life.
The Real-World Results
Kegel Exercise Outcomes (Based on Clinical Studies)
- Success rate: 40-50% see significant improvement
- Time to results: 3-6 months of daily practice
- Adherence rate: Only 30% continue exercises long-term
- Relapse rate: High if exercises are stopped
Translation: Most women either don't see results or can't stick with it long enough to see results.
Emsella Therapy Outcomes (FDA Trial Data)
- Success rate: 95% report significant improvement[3]
- Time to results: Most notice improvement after 2-3 sessions
- Pad reduction: 75% reduce pad usage
- Quality of life: 95% report improved quality of life
- Adherence rate: 98% complete the full 6-session protocol
Translation: It works for almost everyone, works quickly, and people actually complete the treatment.
Cost Analysis: Is Emsella Worth It?
The Free Option (Kegels)
Direct cost: $0
Opportunity cost:
- 15-30 minutes daily for 6 months = 90-180 hours
- Pads/depends during those 6 months = $300-500
- 50% chance it doesn't work = wasted time
- 6 more months of limited activities, anxiety, embarrassment
Total actual cost if it works: ~$500 + 180 hours of your life
Total actual cost if it fails: ~$500 + 180 hours + still have incontinence
The Paid Option (Emsella)
Direct cost: $1,800
Time investment: 6 sessions × 28 minutes = 2.8 hours total
Success rate: 95%
Results timeline: 2-3 weeks
Cost per successful outcome:
- Kegels: Infinite (if they don't work) or ~$500 + 180 hours (if they do)
- Emsella: $1,800 + 3 hours (95% success rate)
If your time is worth anything, Emsella is actually the more cost-effective option.
Can You Combine Both?
Yes, but you don't need to.
Some practitioners recommend doing Kegels alongside Emsella, but clinical data shows Emsella alone is sufficient for most patients. The 11,000 contractions per session provide more than enough stimulus for muscle rebuilding.
That said, once you complete Emsella treatment, doing occasional Kegels (2-3 times per week) can help maintain results long-term.
Who Should Choose Kegels
Try Kegels first if you:
- Have very mild, recent-onset incontinence
- Are highly motivated and disciplined
- Can afford 6 months of trial and error
- Are young with good muscle responsiveness
- Want to try the free option first
But if you don't see improvement after 6-8 weeks of consistent, correct Kegels, move on. Don't waste 6 months hoping it will suddenly start working.
Who Should Choose Emsella
Choose Emsella if you:
- Have moderate to severe incontinence
- Tried Kegels with no improvement
- Want fast results (can't wait 6 months)
- Have a busy schedule (can't do daily exercises)
- Want the highest success rate
- Are postpartum (especially forceps/difficult delivery)
- Are post-menopausal
- Value your time (180 hours vs 3 hours)
The Honest Recommendation
If you have the budget for Emsella and want the fastest, most reliable results, go straight to Emsella. Don't waste 6 months on Kegels that might not work.
If budget is a major concern, try Kegels for 6-8 weeks under the guidance of a pelvic floor physical therapist (to ensure proper form). If you don't see measurable improvement, invest in Emsella.
What you shouldn't do: Spend years doing Kegels hoping they'll eventually work. If they haven't helped after 2-3 months of consistent effort, they're not going to suddenly start working.
Try Emsella in Milwaukee
Bay View Chiropractic offers Emsella pelvic floor therapy with a 95% success rate. Free consultation to see if it's right for you.
Schedule Free ConsultationLocated in Bay View, Milwaukee • (414) 295-6045
References
- Bump RC, Hurt WG, Fantl JA, Wyman JF. Assessment of Kegel pelvic muscle exercise performance after brief verbal instruction. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1991;165(2):322-9.
- Dumoulin C, Cacciari LP, Hay-Smith EJC. Pelvic floor muscle training versus no treatment, or inactive control treatments, for urinary incontinence in women. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018;10:CD005654.
- Samuels JB, Pezzella A, Berenholz J, Alinsod R. Safety and efficacy of a non-invasive high-intensity focused electromagnetic field (HIFEM) device for treatment of urinary incontinence and enhancement of quality of life. Lasers Surg Med. 2019;51(9):760-766.
- Silantyeva E, Zarkovic D, Astafeva E, et al. A comparative study on the effects of high-intensity focused electromagnetic technology and electrostimulation for the treatment of pelvic floor muscles and urinary incontinence in parous women. Female Pelvic Med Reconstr Surg. 2021;27(5):e540-e545.